Skip to main content

Legal protection

After You Use Your Gun

Quick GlanceWhat to do and say after a self-defense shooting in New York: calling 911, when police arrive, your right to an attorney, and why to be covered before it happens. Advice from attorney Peter Tilem.

This product / service / establishment is endorsed by
2A613

Attorney Advertising

If you have just had to use your gun to defend yourself, what you do and say in the next few minutes and hours can matter almost as much as the moment itself. Below is the core advice, in plain words, from New York firearms attorney Peter Tilem, a former Manhattan firearms prosecutor and the founder of NY TAC DEFENSE.

Need Help Right Now?

In danger or someone is hurt: call ⁠911. If possible, have someone else make the call, and ask for police and an ambulance.

NY TAC DEFENSE members: call our 24/7 emergency response line, ⁠(877) 377-8666, as soon as you safely can.

Not a member? Know today which criminal defense attorney you would call, and keep the number in your phone.

At a Glance 911 Make sure 911 is called right away, by someone else if possible. Ask for police and an ambulance. Your gun It must not be in your hand or visible when police arrive. Hands Empty and visible. Follow every command. Medical Tell the police right away that you need medical attention. Words A short, truthful statement: what the attacker did, where the evidence is, and "I want to press charges." Then: "I want to fully cooperate, but I need to go to the hospital and I need an attorney." Scene Don't touch or move anything. Point out evidence and witnesses. After Call your attorney. Make no statement at the station house without medical attention first and your attorney present. Don't post, text or talk about it with anyone else.

General information, not legal advice. Every case is different. Speak to an attorney about your own situation.

Meet Peter Tilem

Peter H. Tilem is the founder and principal of Tilem & Associates, PC in White Plains, New York, and the founder of NY TAC DEFENSE, featured on our NY TAC DEFENSE page. In Peter Tilem's words: “New York's only pre-paid legal service for gun owners.”

35+ Years Licensed in New York

Peter Tilem says he was admitted in Connecticut in 1991, and in New York under a temporary practice order from the Appellate Division as of August 1991. He is currently registered in New York, according to the state's official attorney registration records.

Former Manhattan Prosecutor

Began his career in 1991 as an Assistant District Attorney in the New York County (Manhattan) District Attorney's Office and spent 10 years there, six of them in the firearms trafficking unit, according to his firm. He left in November 2001 as a Senior Prosecutor.

Trained Police and Prosecutors

His firm says he trained police officers and prosecutors, and taught a class on "Excellence in Police Testimony" to cadets at the New York City Police Academy.

A Second Amendment Voice

Quoted as "an attorney who regularly practices in Second Amendment law" by The Journal News (lohud) on 11/28/2023. According to his firm's bio, he has appeared on 60 Minutes and CNN.

He is admitted in the New York and Connecticut state courts, the U.S. Supreme Court, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, and the federal courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York and the District of Connecticut, according to his firm.

One Case From the News

In 2019, The Journal News reported that a Rockland County judge ruled police had no probable cause to arrest two New Jersey men or seize their legally owned guns, and the district attorney dismissed the case. Mr. Tilem represented one of the men.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Why Peter Started NY TAC DEFENSE

"As a prominent Second Amendment attorney serving New York for over 30 years and a gun owner, I could not stand by as you were forced to bear the legal cost for physically defending yourself or your family."

These words are on the NY TAC DEFENSE home page.

Call 911 Right Away

Someone has to call 911, as soon as it is safe. If anyone else is with you, it is better for them to make the call, not you. You have just been through what may be the most traumatic event of your life, and everything said on the call is recorded. If there is no one else, you will have to call yourself.

"My name is ___. I'm at ___ (exact address or location)."

"Someone attacked me." (or: "Someone broke into my home.")

"Someone is hurt. Please send police and an ambulance."

"I'm wearing ___ (clothing), so the officers know who I am."

  • Keep it short. 911 calls are recorded and can be used in court. Give the facts that help responders, not the whole story.

  • Ask for the police and an ambulance for anyone hurt, including the attacker. It shows you meant to stop a threat, not to harm.

  • If the dispatcher keeps asking questions about what happened, you can say: "I'll explain everything once I've spoken with my attorney. Please send help."

  • Tell the dispatcher if you're still armed and where your gun is, so officers are not surprised.

  • Stay where you are and wait for the police to arrive.

Peter's Advice

"Someone has to call 911, and it may have to be you. But if anyone else is available to make the call, it is better for them to do it. You are under the influence of perhaps the most traumatic event of your life, and everything you say is being recorded. Whoever calls should ask for the police and an ambulance.

When the police get there, it is very important that you are not holding a firearm. That's for your safety and for the officers' safety. Even if you have to hold the attacker at gunpoint until the police arrive, make sure the gun is not visible when the officers actually come up on you."

When Police Arrive

The officers who arrive know only that shots were fired. They don't know who the good guy is yet. Your job is to make that obvious and to stay safe.

  1. If the threat is over, holster your gun or set it down before police arrive, if you safely can. Never have it in your hand when officers show up. If you must hold the attacker at gunpoint until police arrive, make sure the gun is out of sight by the time officers reach you.

  2. Keep your hands empty, open and visible. Nothing in them, not even a phone, when officers approach.

  3. Follow every command right away, even if it feels wrong. You may be ordered to the ground, searched and handcuffed. That is normal. Don't argue or explain at that moment.

  4. Don't reach for your gun or tell officers "I have a gun" while moving. Say where it is and let them secure it.

  5. Tell the officers right away that you need medical attention. You have just been through one of the most traumatic experiences of your life, and you cannot be expected to think clearly.

  6. Expect your gun to be taken as evidence. Let them take it.

From the 2A613 Team's Experience

Every attorney we have spoken with about this gives much the same core advice: call 911, keep your hands visible and your words few, and call your lawyer. The steps on this page are that common ground.

Our tip: save the attorney hotline in your phone today. NY TAC DEFENSE members should keep their membership card next to their carry license. In the moment, you won't want to be searching for it.

What to Say, and What Not to Say

You have the right to remain silent and the right to a lawyer. Using them is not a sign of guilt. In the shock and adrenaline right after a shooting, people often misremember details and say things that are wrong, and those words can be used against them later. But saying nothing at all has its own risk. If you say nothing, all the police have is you with a gun and a person on the floor. So have a short statement ready, three or four sentences. Be truthful, accurate and brief:

1. What happened: "That person tried to kill me." (or "tried to stab me," "tried to shoot me," whatever the facts are)

2. Where the evidence is: "His knife is right over there." / "There's a witness over there." / "There's a camera over there."

3. "I want to press charges."

4. "I want to fully cooperate with you, but I need to go to the hospital. I need an attorney, and I will be happy to cooperate once my attorney gets here."

  • Then stop talking about what happened. Say the attorney line clearly and politely, and repeat it if questioning continues.

  • NY TAC DEFENSE members: tell the police you have already hired an attorney for this incident and that you will be happy to cooperate once you have contacted your attorney. Once police know you have a lawyer on the matter, they may not question you until one of our attorneys is with you.

  • Don't lie, guess or fill silence. No "I didn't mean to", no "I just fired", no jokes, and no guessing how many shots or how far away.

  • Ask for medical attention. Saying you need to go to the hospital is not a dodge. A sudden adrenaline drop is real, and you should not be questioned until you have been seen.

  • Give your name and ID as required, and show your carry license when asked, as the law requires in New York.

Peter's Advice

"As criminal defense attorneys, we used to tell our clients, 'Don't say a word.' We've changed that guidance a little, because it's important that the investigation gets started along the right lines. Have two or three sentences ready: what the person tried to do to you, where the police can find the evidence, and that you want to press charges. Then tell them you want to fully cooperate, but you need to go to the hospital and you need an attorney.

In New York, once you tell the police you want an attorney, you cannot give up that right unless an attorney is present. If you're a member of NY TAC DEFENSE, it's even simpler: tell them you have already hired an attorney for this incident, and they cannot speak to you until one of us is there."

At the Scene: Evidence and Witnesses

  • Don't touch, move or pick up anything: not the attacker's weapon, not your shell casings, not anything in the room. Moved evidence can hurt you.

  • Point out evidence the police might miss, such as the attacker's weapon, a broken door or a dropped item, in a few words.

  • Point out witnesses before they leave. Witnesses often walk away. If you can, note names or what they look like.

  • Cameras: mention any doorbell, store or traffic cameras nearby. Footage is often recorded over within days.

  • Don't discuss what happened with witnesses or family at the scene. Their accounts should be their own.

The Hours and Days After

  • Call your attorney, or the NY TAC DEFENSE 24/7 emergency response line if you're a member, as soon as you can, and before any interview.

  • At the station house: in many cases, especially in New York, you will be brought to the station house to be questioned. Do not make a statement unless you have first received medical attention and your attorney is present.

  • With your attorney: tell your attorney the complete story, including where any evidence is, especially evidence the police may not have.

  • No social media. No posts, comments, photos, videos or "likes" about the incident. Prosecutors and the other side's lawyers look for them.

  • Don't text, email or call friends about what happened. Messages can be subpoenaed. Talk about it only with your attorney.

  • Write nothing down except for your attorney, and only as your attorney directs.

  • Look after yourself and your family. Shock, poor sleep and anxiety are common after a shooting. Getting help is a sign of strength.

Peter's Advice

"When a member calls, the first thing that matters is that the police know you already have an attorney. From then on, they cannot question you until one of us is with you. We will meet with you and learn everything that happened, including where any evidence is. Generally, in the first day or so, we contact the prosecutor's office. An experienced attorney can usually tell fairly quickly where the prosecutor thinks the case is going.

If it makes sense for you to talk to the prosecutor, we will make sure a proffer agreement, sometimes called a 'queen for a day' agreement, is in place first. Never go in and speak to law enforcement without one."

What to Expect

  • You may be arrested, even if you were completely justified. In most counties, the police decide whether to charge you together with the prosecutor's office. An arrest is not a conviction.

  • If you are charged: in New York City and many other places, expect to spend 12 to 24 hours waiting to see a judge for arraignment. The judge will then decide whether to hold you, release you on your own recognizance, or set bail or other conditions while the case goes on.

  • Talking to the prosecutor: your attorney will contact the prosecutor's office. If your attorney thinks you should speak with the prosecutor, it should be under a written proffer ("queen for a day") agreement. Under that agreement, what you say at the meeting can't be used against you in the prosecution's direct case, including at a grand jury or at trial. Don't speak with law enforcement without one.

  • Your gun will likely be held as evidence, possibly for a long time.

  • Your carry license may be suspended. New York law lets a licensing officer or judge suspend or revoke a license, and when a license is suspended or revoked the holder must surrender the license and all firearms, rifles and shotguns. In practice, a suspension can follow quickly after a shooting or an arrest.

  • Expect a long process. A self-defense case can go to a grand jury and can take months. A civil lawsuit from the attacker or their family is also possible.

  • Every case turns on its own facts, and every attorney handles a case a little differently. Find an attorney you trust, then follow that attorney's advice.

New York Self-Defense Law: The Basics

New York's self-defense rules are in Article 35 of the Penal Law ("Defense of Justification"). In plain words:

  • Deadly physical force (such as firing a gun) is allowed only when you reasonably believe the other person is using or about to use deadly physical force against you or someone else, or is committing or attempting a kidnapping, forcible rape, forcible aggravated sexual abuse, robbery, or (in the situations in § 35.20) a burglary.

  • Duty to retreat: even then, you may not use deadly force if you know you can avoid it with complete safety, to yourself and others, by retreating.

  • Your home is the exception: there is no duty to retreat in your own dwelling if you were not the initial aggressor.

  • Burglary of a home or occupied building: a person lawfully there may use deadly force when they reasonably believe it is necessary to stop a burglary.

  • No justification if you provoked the attack intending to cause injury, if you started it (unless you clearly withdrew and the other person kept going), or if it was a fight you both agreed to.

Gray Area

Where your "dwelling" ends (a porch, driveway, yard or an apartment building's hallway), what is "reasonable", and how a grand jury will see the facts are questions for a lawyer, not for a web page. ⚠️ Do your own research or speak to an attorney.

For where you may carry at all, see our Police Stop While Carrying guide and the NYC Sensitive Locations page.

Why Get Covered Before You Need It

A self-defense case can be expensive even when you did nothing wrong. With a pre-paid legal service, a lawyer is a phone call away the moment it happens, and the legal fees are already arranged. Every gun owner, especially in New York, should know today who they will call in a worst-case scenario.

Why Before, Not After

You can't sign up after it happens and be covered for it. NY TAC DEFENSE's own terms say criminal defense is provided only if:

"The use of the firearm, or other weapon, in an 'act of self-defense' occurred during the term of client's enrollment in the NY TAC DEFENSE PROGRAM."

NY TAC DEFENSE Terms of Service, Section I.B.1(a)(2). The civil-suit benefit has the same rule: the injury must not have happened before your enrollment began (Section I.A.1(b)).

So the time to join is now, while nothing has happened.

What Members Get

  • 24/7 emergency response line to talk to a lawyer right after any incident: ⁠(877) 377-8666.

  • Wallet membership card with the emergency number and the steps to follow after a defensive incident, to keep next to your carry license.

  • Criminal defense representation for a self-defense use of a legally possessed firearm or other weapon: up to $250,000 (Silver), up to $500,000 (Gold), or unlimited (Platinum).

  • Representation if you are sued by the attacker or their family after an act of self-defense.

  • Red Flag (ERPO) representation if an Extreme Risk Protection Order is sought against you.

  • Members-only group where the firm's lawyers post updates on New York gun laws and answer questions.

  • Gold and Platinum: 25% off the firm's other legal services, including gun license denials, suspensions and revocations (after 6 months of membership).

⁠Good to know: NY TAC DEFENSE is a pre-paid legal service, not insurance. It pays for lawyers, not court judgments, and members pay their own case expenses, such as investigators or experts. Read the full terms before you join.

Plans and Your 10% Code

Prices as of November 2026, from NY TAC DEFENSE's own sign-up and checkout pages. All plans: premier criminal defense representation; members must be 18+.

Silver

$38 / month

or $384 a year ($32 / month, billed annually)

  • Covers 1 person
  • Up to $250,000 of criminal defense representation

With code 2A613: $34.20 / month, or $370 a year

Gold

$74 / month

or $744 a year ($62 / month, billed annually)

  • Covers 1-4 people
  • Up to $500,000 of criminal defense representation
  • 25% discount on other legal services

With code 2A613: $66.60 / month, or $669.60 a year

Platinum

$149 / month

or $1,464 a year ($122 / month, billed annually)

  • Covers 1-4 people
  • Unlimited criminal defense representation
  • 25% discount on other legal services

With code 2A613: $134.10 / month, or $1,317.60 a year

Your 10% Code

2A613

Code 2A613 takes 10% off every plan except Silver Annual, which it brings from $384 to $370 a year.

Type the code at checkout ("Click here to enter your promotional/gift code"). Prices as of November 2026.

Sign up and share this message with your 2A friends who will appreciate it.

Sign Up for NY TAC DEFENSE

More details: our NY TAC DEFENSE page. The 2A613 Team does not receive a referral fee.

Sources and Disclosures

⁠New to the terms? See the 2A Glossary.

To be accepted into our chats: after tapping Join, send us a message through the Contact Us page, choose “Join WhatsApp Groups Request”, then reply to the automatic email with all the requested details.

White Glove Service

Your Application, Handled From Start to Finish.

One-on-one help with new applications and renewals. The decision to carry is yours; the paperwork, the checklists and the scheduling are ours.

  • We Prepare the PaperworkEvery form filled out and submitted for you, with your authorization. Notary services available.*
  • We Check Every DocumentEvery requirement checked before anything goes in.
  • You Show Up ReadyYour 18-hour training scheduled, and you're prepped for fingerprinting and the interview.

Three Steps. Zero Guesswork.

  1. 1
    Tell Us What You NeedFill out the short request form.
  2. 2
    We Review & AdviseWe review your situation and advise on the best approach.
  3. 3
    You Apply With ConfidenceYour packet goes in complete, and we stay with you to the finish line.

Every completed application we've handled so far has been approved — but approval is always the agency's decision.

Or message us on WhatsApp

A paid service. Every free guide stays free. The initial consultation is free. No paid work starts until you agree to the quote and a paid deposit, which is determined during the initial consultation. *Additional fees and restrictions apply. Past results do not guarantee future approval.

Join the 2A613 Community

Take our community survey and subscribe to updates. We only email about important topics and never sell your email to third parties.

Take the survey

Last updated: 11/17/2026 · ז׳ כסלו תשפ״ז

WhatsApp Channel

New: 2A613.com Updates channel

All 2A613 updates are posted only on this Channel: website news, carry law changes for NY, NJ and every state, reciprocity map updates, upcoming events, classes and deals.

Already in our WhatsApp Community? These updates won’t appear in the Community chats. They’re separate, so follow the Channel too.

Don’t want to be busy with group chats? Just want the important updates? This is the channel to follow.

  • Broadcast only, no chatter
  • Your number stays private
Follow on WhatsAppShare with friends on WhatsApp

Please share with friends who carry or are applying